Sex and Gender.

I think I may have discovered another area of medicine that I’d like to do more of – primary care of the transgendered individual.

In the past two years I have had 3 individuals disclose to me their desire to change their gender.  It is a fascinating area of medicine, one that I know almost nothing about, but that is all about to change.

Before my maternity leave, one of these transgendered individuals told me about a comprehensive guide developed by the local trans community for primary care physicians.  He gave me the website and I downloaded the guide (about 100 pages) and planned to read it while I was off.  Sadly, it remained on my desk  unread for 6 months, until today!

Gender Identity Disorder is a recognized psychiatric illness in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Mental Disorders (DSM-IV), though labeling it as a “psychiatric” illness does little to ease the stigma for these individuals. Thus, a change in terminology is being implemented with the new edition of the manual:

In the upcoming fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5), people whose gender at birth is contrary to the one they identify with will be diagnosed with gender dysphoria. This diagnosis is a revision of DSM-IV’s criteria for gender identity disorder and is intended to better characterize the experiences of affected children, adolescents, and adults.

The core criteria for diagnosis of Gender Dysphoria are the following:

  • Cross-gender identification
  • Desire to live as a member of the other sex
  • Sense of inappropriateness in the gender role belonging
  • to one’s natal sex
  • Discomfort about one’s assigned sex
  • Desire to have sex characteristics of the other sex
  • Discomfort about one’s anatomic sex 
  • Wish to get rid of one’s natal sex characteristics

All of my patients who have told me they desire to be the opposite sex fit the above criteria.  In my city, there is a multidisciplinary clinic dedicated to Gender Dysphoria and I have referred them all.  Only one has been seen and he recently had chest surgery (ie. elective bilateral mastectomy).  Unfortunately, the wait list is close to 2 years and for the majority of patients seeking to start treatment, this can be an excruciating wait.

Imagine feeling like you were born into the wrong body. Imagine coming to terms with wanting to be the opposite sex. Imagine “coming out” to your family and friends. Imagine the feeling of dressing like the gender you wish to be for the first time.  Imagine telling your family doctor, then imagine having to wait 2 more years to get treatment.  Can you imagine what that must feel like?

I saw such a patient this week.  “He” is a genetic male but has never felt comfortable with his male genitalia.  “He” wants to be a female.  “He” wants all of his male organs removed permanently.  “He” wants to be a “She”. She has picked out her new name and really, really, really wants to start hormone therapy.  She looked at me with desperation in her eyes.  “Can you please help me?”

This patient has been referred to the multidisciplinary clinic and is on a very long waiting list.  The initial referral was made over a year ago and we were told the wait was minimum 16 months.  In the meantime, the patient has gone to trans support groups, has come out to all of her friends and family and is now ready to start making the transition physically.  She eventually wants sex reassignment surgery but realistically, this won’t happen for a few years. In the mean time, she is ready to start looking more female.

She wants to start hormones. My initial thought was, “I can’t do that. I don’t know what to start!” Then I remembered the guidelines handbook my other patient gave me, which I never got around to reading.  While the patient was in the examination room, I went to my office and got it off the pile of other reading on my desk.  I quickly flipped to the section  “Hormone therapy for the male-to-female transgendered individual”.  Together with the patient, I read the guidelines and at the end of the 30+ minute appointment, the patient was given a prescription for an anti-androgen; the first side effects of which would be lessening of coarse facial hair and cessation of spontaneous erections.  The latter side effect made the patient smile with relief.

I sent the patient home with a requisition for baseline blood work, a prescription for the anti-androgen, and a follow-up appointment in a month.

I have to say, it was a such an amazingly satisfying encounter.  I could see the relief on the patient’s face when she realized I would support and assist her in starting hormonal treatment.  I felt like I really made an impact.

As I mentioned at the outset, it’s a growing field of medicine that I feel privileged and honored to be a part of.  These individuals need more physicians to advocate for them.  I hope to become one such physician.



12 thoughts on “Sex and Gender.

  1. This made me tear up. We were just reviewing the change from DSM IV to V in terms of gender dysphoria this week and although I think it still has ENORMOUS stigma (in part because it’s in the DSM at all), I’m grateful that it at least enables us (by making it billable to insurance) to help patients who are struggling with issues related to sex and gender. I’ll be interested to read more about your learning process because like you, I feel utterly underprepared to help this patient population and feel strongly that it’s an area where we can make huge improvements.

    • Thanks so much for your comments! My girlfriend took a gender equity course and is going to lend me a few of her textbooks. I’m looking forward to reading more on the topic.

  2. A really nice post. What a huge difference you have made to this girl’s life, she will have been so anxious to
    come and discuss this and must be thrilled to have had such a good consultation with a good outcome.

  3. This is fantastic. I am so happy you were able to help her and it is so sad that there is such a long wait list. I can’t imagine. Patients are lucky to have you as their doctor.

  4. I have operated on several of these patients as plastic surgeon. The psychology behind these patients are complex. Their struggles with their identity cannot be solved with just changing their appearance. The expectations they have from their surgery is usually unrealistic as they tend to expect the surgery to cure them of their identity issues – which unfortunately doesn’t happen especially after their initial elation wears off. They need ongoing support from interested physicians… people like you who have genuine interest in them.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s